We love the Florida Keys so much that we named our youngest daughter Mara after Marathon Key. It is heaven on earth for us. The sun, salty air and food are hard to beat. In the Keys, the most famous must-have dessert is key lime pie. You can find it at gas stations, food trucks, pie stores and street vendors. In our quest to find insane milkshakes, Big Hoffa’s Freezery not only had us at the everything-in-the-kitchen-sugar-drawer Tears of a Mermaid, but this Caribbean Cay milkshake makes us scream, “It’s 5 o’clock somewhere!” and takes us straight to Mallory Square.

Get one today at
BIG HOFFA’S FREEZERY
800 E. Main St., Westfield
www.BigHoffas.com



Subscribe today!

FOLLOW

about us

At Edible Indy, we celebrate you and the incredible flavors, experiences, and connections that define Indianapolis and its surrounding areas. From locally sourced ingredients to expertly crafted cocktails, we shine a spotlight on the vibrant food and drink scene right here in Central Indiana.

Whether you’re savoring a farm-to-table meal at your favorite restaurant, exploring the city’s buzzing cocktail culture, or discovering a hidden neighborhood café, we’re here to connect you to the stories, people, and places that make our region so special.

WHERE TO FIND US

CONNECT

EDIBLE INDY HQ

1020 Clinton St.
Suite 210
Noblesville, IN 46060

©2026 edible INDY. All rights reserved. PART OF THE AGM FAMILY OF BRANDS.

Privacy Preference Center