It’s time to ditch the same old dinner-and-a-movie date night routine. When the weather gets cold and the family gatherings start piling up for the holidays, it can feel difficult to carve out special outings for your significant other. We’ve compiled three date night ideas that go beyond the basics to turn a typical night out into a scene straight out of a Hallmark movie. But of course, all of our picks are foodie-focused to ensure your evening together is as tasty as it is fun.

Explore your favorite neighborhood with a progressive dinner

There’s something adventurous about a night out that unfolds in courses. Instead of committing to one restaurant, a progressive dinner lets you sample an entire neighborhood’s food scene. While you could map out a route in any neighborhood, we’ve selected Fountain Square for its walkable streets, eclectic ambiance, and restaurants made for lingering.

Image courtesy of Monti

We’ll start the night at Monti for aperitivo. Aperitivo is the Italian ritual of pre-dinner drinks and snacks to stimulate the appetite, making this the ideal precursor to your evening. Monti welcomes you with a select pour of aperitif to open your palate. The ample bar space and happy hour menu is built for grazing with spritzes, negronis, light bar snacks, small plates and more.

Next up is dinner at Bluebeard, just a half mile down the road. With a menu that rotates almost daily, you might never have the same meal twice. You will always find seasonal variations of vegetable-focused meals and fresh, scratch-made pasta dishes, making it the perfect follow-up to aperitivo.

Image courtesy of amelia's bakery
Image courtesy of Bluebeard

Head next door for our final stop: Amelia’s for dessert. When cold winter nights call for a warm sweet treat, Amelia’s pastries, made fresh daily, deliver. The bakery is open until 8pm nightly, with a mix of staples and specials that rotate semi-regularly. Their core menu features cookies, croissants, cinnamon rolls, brownies, and more.

For a bit of an extended evening, add in a round of duckpin bowling, a show at the Hi-Fi, or a stroll through First Friday at the Murphy, which generally runs until 10pm.

Book a couples class for a hands-on experience

Nothing says quality time like learning something new together. A culinary class adds an element of teamwork to your night out, no matter what skill you’re looking to hone. It can also double as an experience-based gift idea for the holidays.

At Sur La Table in Carmel, every cooking class is led by a chef instructor. There’s no shortage of options, whether you’re looking to try your hand as a French pastry chef, craft the perfect sushi roll, whip up a curry, or learn the art of a Tuscan dinner. 

The November and December class schedule is full of festive sessions including cookie making, harvest sweets, holiday feasts, classic comforts, and more.

For couples who love wine, up your vino knowledge in time for Thanksgiving at Westfield Wine Vault. They offer approachable wine classes with their 101 and Pour Decisions series. While you sip, learn about various wine regions and the nuances of how to taste and appreciate your next glass. Upcoming classes include pairings for holiday dishes and sweets, and a lesson in bubbly for the New Year.

Image courtesy of black dog brewing

To get behind the bar, head to Black Dog Brewing Co. in Fountain Square for a Beer or Mixology 101 class. Beer 101 provides an introduction to beer styles, tasting techniques, and the basics of brewing. Meanwhile, Mixology 101 teaches the fundamentals of spirits and cocktail making.

Turn up the heat with at-home culinary challenges

For those who don’t want to brave the cold, there are plenty of ways to cook up some creative connection at home. These competitions invite you to turn your kitchen into a pop-up bar or a mini test kitchen and put your skills to the test.

For the mixologists: Each of you makes a drink for the other. You can either choose a handful of random spirits, mixers, and garnishes for the other to use mystery-box style, or agree on a shared stash of ingredients and see who comes up with the better drink. Set a time limit and score each other based on taste, creativity, and presentation. Whoever wins gets to choose your takeout order.

For the chefs: Pick an assortment of pantry staples, proteins, and produce to build a dish around for each other. To add a twist, each partner gets to sneak in a few surprise ingredients for the other. The same rules apply: Agree on a time limit and scoring criteria ahead of time to choose a winner. The loser cleans up or plans the next date.

This season, escape the hustle and bustle together by exploring a new neighborhood, learning a new skill, or channeling your inner chef.

RELATED STORIES

Hattie’s Coffee House: The Community Room/Coffee Shop in a Whitestown Farmhouse

Founded in 2023, Hattie’s Coffee House sits on Main Street in Whitestown just as the road changes to 650 East.

Read More

Miracle Pop-Up Bar Returns to Indy for 2026

The holiday pop-up bar Miracle is returning to Indianapolis at the Exchange on Mass Ave. From November 23, guests can enjoy…

Read More

RECIPE: Fontainebleau

Creamy, tangy mousse with a jam finish; this dessert whips up in about 20 minutes for a decadent midweek indulgence or a…

Read More



Subscribe today!

FOLLOW

about us

At Edible Indy, we celebrate you and the incredible flavors, experiences, and connections that define Indianapolis and its surrounding areas. From locally sourced ingredients to expertly crafted cocktails, we shine a spotlight on the vibrant food and drink scene right here in Central Indiana.

Whether you’re savoring a farm-to-table meal at your favorite restaurant, exploring the city’s buzzing cocktail culture, or discovering a hidden neighborhood café, we’re here to connect you to the stories, people, and places that make our region so special.

WHERE TO FIND US

CONNECT

EDIBLE INDY HQ

1020 Clinton St.
Suite 210
Noblesville, IN 46060

©2026 edible INDY. All rights reserved. PART OF THE AGM FAMILY OF BRANDS.

Privacy Preference Center