A toasty holiday cocktail requires just a bit of at-home mixology, with a fun warm result. With two types of rum and a delectable coconut cream, this recipe balances dark and light to last the long nights. You can find bartender Claire McGuinness’ coconut creation at both Grindstone Public House and Grindstone on the Monon. For those making it at home, the honey and cinnamon syrup and coconut cream also pair well with coffee for a cozy coconut mielle.

1.5 oz Plantaray Dark Rum

1 oz Hard Truth Toasted Coconut Rum

1 oz coconut cream*(2 part milk, 1 part cream)

.75 oz honey cinnamon simple syrup**

Build in shaker, shake and pour over fresh ice into double rocks glass rimmed in cinnamon sugar, dust with nutmeg

*Coconut Cream

House blend of one part Real Coconut Cream and two parts coconut milk

**Honey Cinnamon Simple

Mix one cup hot water, one cup honey and one tablespoon cinnamon until dissolved. Let cool to room temperature before refrigerating

RELATED STORIES

The Flavors of Fall: Four Cozy Bakes for Autumn Days

We're keeping things simple at home with classic fall flavors to add to your annual repetoire.

Read More

RECIPE: Classic Apple Pie

who doesn't love a classic? This decadent apple pie is perfect for the crispy, sweet September harvest, and the holidays to…

Read More

RECIPE: Cinnamon Sugar Donut Bread

Cinnamon and sugar combine with the texture of a cake donut for a loaf perfect for slicing. Pair with your morning cup of…

Read More



Subscribe today!

FOLLOW

about us

At Edible Indy, we celebrate you and the incredible flavors, experiences, and connections that define Indianapolis and its surrounding areas. From locally sourced ingredients to expertly crafted cocktails, we shine a spotlight on the vibrant food and drink scene right here in Central Indiana.

Whether you’re savoring a farm-to-table meal at your favorite restaurant, exploring the city’s buzzing cocktail culture, or discovering a hidden neighborhood café, we’re here to connect you to the stories, people, and places that make our region so special.

WHERE TO FIND US

CONNECT

EDIBLE INDY HQ

1020 Clinton St.
Suite 210
Noblesville, IN 46060

©2026 edible INDY. All rights reserved. PART OF THE AGM FAMILY OF BRANDS.

Privacy Preference Center