We’re bringing you a New England classic. We’re keeping it classy and coastal this Thanksgiving with this recipe for crabbies. If you can’t host your friends at a gorgeous cedar-shingled Cape house on Martha’s Vineyard, you can at least take their taste buds there. It may have been a brat summer, but it’s a coastal grandmother fall.

This crabbies recipe makes for an easy but essential appetizer made of English muffins, crab meat, and a cheddar cheese spread. Pop these in the oven as your first guests arrive for the perfect warm, cheesy start to the evening.

Crabbies recipe

CRABBIES

½ cup salted butter, softened

1 (5-ounce) jar Kraft Old English Spread cheese

1½ teaspoons mayo

½ teaspoon garlic powder

7 ounces crabmeat

6 English muffins

Combine salted butter, Kraft Old English Spread, mayo, garlic powder and crabmeat in a bowl and mix well.

Separate the English muffin halves and place on a foil-lined baking sheet that will fit in your freezer. Spread the cheese-crab mixture evenly between the 12 English muffin pieces.

Cover with plastic wrap and freeze for 1 hour.

Uncover and broil in the oven for 5 minutes, until golden brown. Cut the crabbies into quarters and serve.

RELATED STORIES

The Science of Seasoning Cast Iron

Cast iron’s surface is naturally rough and porous, and heating a small amount of oil in the pan triggers a chemical process…

Read More

Cocktail Recipe: The Two-Ingredient Kir Royale

The simple combination of champagne and creme de cassis makes for the elevated blackberry spritz that is the Kir Royale.

Read More

A Cozy French Holiday Menu You Can Make Days Ahead

Rich cassoulet, a punchy fennel and olive salad, and a cloud-like French dessert, all made ahead for an easy holiday dinner.

Read More



Subscribe today!

FOLLOW

about us

At Edible Indy, we celebrate you and the incredible flavors, experiences, and connections that define Indianapolis and its surrounding areas. From locally sourced ingredients to expertly crafted cocktails, we shine a spotlight on the vibrant food and drink scene right here in Central Indiana.

Whether you’re savoring a farm-to-table meal at your favorite restaurant, exploring the city’s buzzing cocktail culture, or discovering a hidden neighborhood café, we’re here to connect you to the stories, people, and places that make our region so special.

WHERE TO FIND US

CONNECT

EDIBLE INDY HQ

1020 Clinton St.
Suite 210
Noblesville, IN 46060

©2026 edible INDY. All rights reserved. PART OF THE AGM FAMILY OF BRANDS.

Privacy Preference Center